Clutter & Health/Safety

Is it Collecting, Chronic Disorganisation, hoarding behaviours or Hoarding Disorder?

Not everyone who has excessive amounts of belongings (including in off-site storage units, other homes, lodged with friends/family, etc) would be classified as someone with hoarding behaviours or Hoarding Disorder.

Hoarding Disorder

In 2018 the World Health Organisation (WHO) classified Hoarding Disorder as a mental illness, and it has included it in the ICD-11– the International Classification of Diseases 11th Revision – the Global standard for diagnostic health information.

Chronic Disorganisation

Whilst The Care Act 2014 recognises hoarding behaviours as one of the manifestations of self-neglect – and requires all public bodies to safeguard people at risk – it’s important to note that living in a chronically disorganised home can be as overwhelming, incapacitating and disabling as living in a hoarded home.

There can be as many environmental, safety or self-neglect issues as with properties where hoarding behaviours are present.

Medical conditions & contributory factors

There are countless reasons and as many medical conditions which can influence a person’s decision to acquire or purchase items, as well as their ability (or otherwise) to reduce the number of possessions leaving their home.

Usually a combination of factors are involved, such as:

  • life events (eg. bereavement)
  • traumas (eg. Adverse Childhood Experiences – ACES)
  • mental health issues (eg. Anxiety; Depression; PTSD; OCD; Dementia)
  • neurological conditions (eg. ADHD; Autism; Dyslexia; Dyspraxia; Chronic Fatigue Syndrome/ME)
  • conditions related to frontal lobe impairments (eg. Acquired Brain Injury – ABI)
  • anything likely to affect a person’s Executive Functioning. 
    • Executive Dysfunction/Dysregulation can inhibit a person’s ability to plan; organise; prioritise; start/finish tasks; make decisions; be flexible with their thinking; remember things; control their impulses; self-monitor; and regulate their emotions.
    • Examples of how Executive Dysfunction can manifest itself in the context of clutter, disorganisation and hoarding include difficulties with things like: opening and dealing with mail; bill paying; deciding where to store items (eg. documents, keys, etc) and remembering where they’ve been stored so they can be retrieved; deciding what to keep and what is surplus to requirements, etc.

Clutter-related health issues can affect anyone

It’s not just the person who accumulates possessions whose health can be impacted – there are thousands of family members around the World who can testify to experiencing health and other problems as a result of a relative’s clutter, disorganisation or hoarding tendencies. For example:

  • depression, high blood pressure and Diabetes are common in those whose homes have become too troublesome for them to deal with
  • debt can occur if compulsive shopping gets out of hand, which can lead to conditions such as anxiety or depression.
  • mould can cause serious problems for people with breathing difficulties such as asthma, or skin conditions such as eczema.
  • an inability to make decisions about what to get rid of and what to keep can lead to anxiety, depression and other mental health problems.
  • Relatives affected may be anxious about the health and wellbeing of family members, and its not uncommon for them to disconnect with their loved one if they don’t comply with their demands to keep things tidy or stop acquiring items. Equally a person with lived experiences may choose to stop all contact with family members if they push them too hard to declutter, attempt forced clearances or remove items without permission..

Goodbye Stigma!

Sadly, many people perceive there is a stigma about having a cluttered, dirty or untidy home; it perpetuates the myth that “Cleanliness is next to Godliness”. The anxiety that people feel because of the fear of being judged and labelled “lazy, dirty or useless” is very real, and is one of the key reasons people feel too embarrassed to invite people into their homes, or to engage with agencies.

Especially if they have underlying conditions like Autism/Asperger’s (often undiagnosed), which can mean they struggle with things like meeting new people; making phone calls or travelling on public transport.

Thanks to hugely successful UK campaigns such as Time To Change (run by the mental health charities Mind and Rethink Mental Illness) and Heads Together (a mental health initiative spearheaded by The Royal Foundation of The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge and The Duke and Duchess of Sussex), the stigma of mental ill health in general is gradually diminishing as people become more comfortable about discussing their mental health and wellbeing, and Mentally Healthy schools are being introduced in the UK.

So, now that Hoarding Disorder has been officially recognised as a mental illness, and there is far more education available about this very emotive subject, we hope that stigmas and misunderstandings about hoarding will soon disappear too.

How could the Hoarding Ice-Breaker save your life?

Having too much stuff in your home can create all sorts of problems – not just for you but your family, neighbours, agencies who need to visit you (eg. carers) and members of the emergency services.

Any Fire Fighter or Paramedic will tell you that minutes spent having to find people amongst the clutter in their homes, or climbing over obstacles or moving things out of the way to get in or out of a property can be the difference between life and death in an emergency.ow

This video shows just how quickly a fire can spread in a hoarded home.

Help and support

In recent years it’s been proven that the most effective way to achieve long-term progress to overcome hoarding behaviours is for multiple agencies to collaborate and provide empathetic, person-centred, practical help and support.

Support groups offer a great way of meeting with others with similar experiences. For more information about locations of support groups around the UK, check out our Resources page.

Professional Hoarding Practitioners work 1:1 with clients in their homes if practical support and assistance with decision-making is required.

For more information

If you would like to know more about how clutter, disorganisation, compulsive shopping/acquiring and hoarding are related to health:

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close